Your diamond engagement ring represents a significant milestone in your life. But as your relationship grows, your tastes and lifestyle might evolve too. Whether it’s your anniversary, a celebration of a life event, or simply the desire for a fresh look, upgrading your engagement ring can breathe new life into this precious symbol.

Here are the best ways to upgrade your diamond engagement ring while keeping the sentimental value intact. If you're looking for inspiration, check out our stunning engagement rings collection.

Reasons to Upgrade Your Diamond Engagement Ring

Upgrading your engagement ring can be a deeply personal decision, and there are many reasons why people choose to enhance their rings over time. Perhaps your original ring was chosen with a more limited budget in mind, or your style has evolved.

Reve Diamonds

You might also be celebrating a major life event like an anniversary or the birth of a child. Upgrading doesn’t take away from the love and meaning behind your original ring—it’s a way to celebrate your relationship's journey and create a new chapter of your love story.

No matter the reason, there are countless ways to give your ring an upgrade that will make it even more special than it already is.

How to Upgrade Your Diamond for Maximum Impact

One of the most popular ways to upgrade an engagement ring is by enhancing the diamond itself. This could mean increasing the size of the stone or opting for a higher quality in terms of cut, clarity, or color. A larger diamond instantly makes the ring feel more luxurious, while a higher-quality stone will sparkle with extra brilliance.

Upgrading the cut is especially impactful because a well-cut diamond reflects more light, creating that coveted sparkle and fire.

If your original ring has a diamond that you adore but want to upgrade its appearance, consider enhancing the cut for a more radiant look without changing the size or shape.

Genuine Story: A couple I know decided to upgrade their engagement ring for their 10th wedding anniversary. They swapped their original stone for a larger round-cut diamond. The new diamond sparkled with an intensity that reflected the strength and growth of their relationship, turning their engagement ring into an even more cherished treasure.

Looking for something bolder? Consider exploring our large diamond rings for a show-stopping upgrade.

Refresh Your Ring with a New Diamond Shape

Changing the shape of your diamond can completely transform the look of your engagement ring. If you’re craving something modern, unique, or simply different from the original style, swapping your diamond’s shape can give you that fresh start.

Oval, pear, and emerald-cut diamonds have become popular options for those seeking a more distinct look. An oval diamond offers a soft, elongated silhouette that gives off an elegant and romantic vibe.

Pear-shaped diamonds, with their unique teardrop design, are perfect for brides who want something bold and different. Emerald cuts, with their clean lines and step-cut facets, offer a sophisticated, vintage-inspired aesthetic.

Genuine Story: A bride who originally had a round-cut diamond ring upgraded to a pear-shaped stone for her 5th anniversary. She loved how the pear shape added a touch of individuality and modernity to her ring while maintaining a timeless beauty.

If you want to explore different options, check out our collection of lab-grown diamonds for eco-friendly, high-quality choices.

Create a Bolder Look by Adding a Halo Setting

If you want to make a bold impact without changing the diamond itself, consider adding a halo setting. A halo consists of smaller diamonds that encircle the center stone, making the diamond appear larger and adding extra sparkle.

The halo effect gives a ring a glamorous, eye-catching appeal, and it can instantly turn a simple solitaire into a dazzling masterpiece. This setting also allows you to play with different metals or stone types.

For example, you could add a rose gold halo around a white diamond for a trendy mixed-metal look, or surround your diamond with colored gemstones for an extra pop of color.

Genuine Story: A couple I know chose to upgrade their engagement ring with a halo setting for their 15th anniversary. The new design added more sparkle to the ring, and the halo gave the original diamond a larger and more luxurious appearance, making the ring feel brand new.

For a sparkling upgrade like this, check out our engagement rings and see how different settings can enhance your diamond.

Update Your Engagement Ring with a New Band

Sometimes, a simple change to the band can dramatically enhance the overall appearance of your ring. If you’re happy with your diamond but want a fresh look, consider changing the band to a different metal or adding unique design details. You might opt for a thicker band for a more substantial feel or switch from white gold to platinum for added durability.

Some brides also choose to incorporate intricate details like milgrain edges, filigree, or engraving for a more vintage-inspired look. These changes allow you to maintain the sentiment of the original diamond while giving the ring a whole new aesthetic.

Genuine Story: One bride swapped her white gold band for a rose gold one. This simple change gave her ring a warmer, more romantic look while keeping the original diamond, allowing her to embrace a contemporary style while retaining its sentimental value.

For a fresh look, explore our collection of wedding bands and see how a new band can completely transform your ring.

Enhance Your Ring with Accent Diamonds or Side Stones

Adding accent diamonds or side stones is a fantastic way to upgrade your engagement ring. Accent diamonds bring additional sparkle, while side stones can create a more intricate and personalized design. You can add smaller diamonds along the band or flank the main stone with baguette diamonds or colored gemstones for a customized look.

If you love a little extra color, consider adding sapphires, rubies, or emeralds as side stones.

These colored gems add a touch of personalization while enhancing the beauty of your central diamond.

Genuine Story: A couple added blue sapphires as side stones to their engagement ring as a nod to their wedding’s beach theme. The blue sapphires not only enhanced the diamond but also gave the ring a personal and unique flair that celebrated their special day.

For more inspiration on how to add extra brilliance, browse our diamond pendants and necklaces.

Transform Your Ring into a Custom Design

For those who want something truly special, consider completely redesigning your engagement ring. A custom design allows you to create a ring that reflects your current style while keeping the sentimental elements of the original piece. You can incorporate diamonds from a family heirloom, add new design elements like split shanks or twist bands, or even turn your solitaire into a more ornate setting.

The beauty of a custom design is that it can be as unique as your relationship, blending old memories with new elements for a ring that tells your full love story.

Genuine Story: One woman transformed her engagement ring by incorporating diamonds from her grandmother’s wedding ring. The result was a custom piece that honored both her own marriage and her family’s legacy, making it a true heirloom to pass down.

Upgrade Your Ring by Stacking with an Anniversary Band

Another beautiful way to upgrade your engagement ring is by stacking it with an eternity or anniversary band. This approach allows you to keep your original engagement ring while adding more sparkle and significance to your bridal set. Eternity bands, featuring diamonds all around the band, are particularly popular for their continuous sparkle and symbolism of eternal love.

You can choose a complementary metal or even a contrasting one to make the stack stand out.

Genuine Story: To celebrate their 20th anniversary, one couple added an eternity band to the bride’s engagement ring. The new addition symbolized the lasting bond they had built over two decades and created a stunning ring stack that she proudly wears every day.

Interested in stacking your ring with something extra special? Explore our collection of eternity rings for that perfect addition.

Revitalize Your Ring with a New Setting

Changing the setting of your diamond can dramatically alter its appearance and even make it more practical. If you’re looking for a more modern or durable design, consider switching from a prong setting to a bezel or tension setting. A bezel setting surrounds the diamond with metal, giving it a sleek, modern look while providing extra protection.

Tension settings hold the diamond in place with pressure, offering a contemporary, minimalist appearance.

These settings are perfect for those looking to modernize their ring without changing the diamond itself.

Genuine Story: One couple decided to switch from a traditional prong setting to a bezel setting to protect the diamond and give their ring a more streamlined look.

The new setting added a modern touch while ensuring the diamond was secure for everyday wear.

FAQs About Upgrading Your Engagement Ring

When is the best time to upgrade an engagement ring?

The best time to upgrade your engagement ring is often during a significant milestone, such as an anniversary, a birthday, or the birth of a child. However, there’s no set rule—upgrade when you feel ready and excited to celebrate the evolution of your relationship.

Can I upgrade without replacing the original diamond?

Absolutely! Many couples choose to keep the original diamond and simply upgrade the setting, band, or add new design elements. This way, you can maintain the sentimental value of the original stone while refreshing its look.

How much does it cost to upgrade an engagement ring?

The cost of upgrading your engagement ring varies widely depending on what changes you make. Simple upgrades like adding accent diamonds or changing the band may cost a few hundred dollars, while more significant upgrades like increasing the diamond size or creating a custom design can range into the thousands.

Will upgrading my engagement ring reduce its value?

Not necessarily. If you upgrade with higher-quality diamonds or settings, your ring's value may actually increase. The key is to work with a reputable jeweler to ensure any changes enhance both the sentimental and financial value of your ring.

Why Upgrading Your Engagement Ring Is the Perfect Way to Celebrate Milestones

Upgrading your engagement ring is a beautiful way to celebrate your relationship’s growth and evolution.

Whether you want to enhance the diamond, change the design, or add a complementary band, there are countless ways to make your ring feel new again while preserving its sentimental value.

As your love story continues, your engagement ring can reflect every special moment you’ve shared and the bright future ahead.

Reve Diamonds