Choosing the perfect engagement ring is one of the most exciting—and sometimes nerve-wracking—decisions you’ll make in your life. Among the sea of options, two popular choices stand out: diamond and moissanite. Both are stunning in their own right, but which one is truly better for you? In this article, we’ll dive into the characteristics of both gemstones, comparing everything from brilliance to cost, so you can make an informed decision that you’ll cherish forever.

What Are Diamonds and Moissanite?

Diamonds are the traditional go-to for engagement rings. Formed under intense heat and pressure deep within the Earth, diamonds are renowned for their unmatched hardness and timeless appeal. They have been symbols of love and commitment for centuries, often passed down through generations as family heirlooms. If you’re leaning toward a classic look, you can explore a variety of options by checking out our engagement rings.

Reve Diamonds

Moissanite, on the other hand, is a relatively new contender in the world of gemstones. Originally discovered in a meteorite by Dr. Henri Moissan, this gemstone is composed of silicon carbide. Today, most moissanite is lab-created, offering an ethical and sustainable option without sacrificing beauty. If you’re interested in sustainable options, consider exploring our lab-grown diamonds.

The Brilliance and Fire: Which Sparkles More?

When it comes to sparkle, both diamonds and moissanite are known for their brilliance, but they achieve it differently.

Diamonds have a refractive index of 2.42, giving them a brilliant sparkle that’s often referred to as "fire." This characteristic is one of the reasons diamonds are so coveted. Their light performance, including brilliance, fire, and scintillation, is unparalleled. For those seeking maximum sparkle, explore our large diamond rings to find a piece that truly shines.

Moissanite has an even higher refractive index of 2.65, making it technically more brilliant than a diamond. However, this extra sparkle can sometimes appear too intense for those accustomed to the classic look of diamonds. Moissanite’s fire is more colorful and pronounced, which some people love, while others may find it a bit flashy.

Durability: Which Gemstone Is Tougher?

Durability is a crucial factor to consider when choosing a gemstone for a piece of jewelry that will be worn every day, like an engagement ring.

Diamonds score a perfect 10 on the Mohs scale of hardness, making them the hardest natural substance on Earth. This hardness ensures that a diamond is resistant to scratches, making it ideal for daily wear. For long-lasting brilliance, consider pairing your ring with one of our durable wedding bands.

Moissanite isn’t far behind, scoring 9.25 on the Mohs scale. While slightly softer than a diamond, it’s still incredibly durable and suitable for everyday use. Moissanite’s toughness also means it’s less likely to chip or break compared to some other gemstones.

Appearance: Can You Tell the Difference?

At first glance, many people find it difficult to tell the difference between a diamond and moissanite. However, upon closer inspection, subtle differences emerge.

Diamonds have a unique, understated brilliance that many describe as icy or steely. This classic appearance is what most people think of when they imagine an engagement ring. If you appreciate this classic look, explore our collection of diamond pendants and necklaces to complement your engagement ring.

Moissanite often displays more colorful flashes of light due to its higher dispersion. This characteristic gives moissanite its distinctive "rainbow effect," which can be more pronounced in larger stones. Some people adore this extra sparkle, while others prefer the more subtle brilliance of diamonds.

Cost: What’s the Difference in Price?

The cost difference between diamonds and moissanite is one of the most significant factors for many couples.

Diamonds are considerably more expensive, with prices varying widely depending on the Four Cs (cut, color, clarity, and carat weight). A one-carat diamond of high quality can easily cost several thousand dollars, making it a significant investment. For those on a budget, exploring alternatives like eternity rings might be a stylish and affordable choice.

Moissanite, however, is much more affordable. You can purchase a one-carat moissanite for a fraction of the cost of a diamond. This affordability allows couples to either save money or opt for a larger stone without breaking the bank.

Ethical Considerations: Which Is More Sustainable?

As awareness of ethical and environmental concerns grows, many couples are considering the origins of their gemstones.

Diamonds have a controversial history, particularly regarding conflict diamonds, also known as blood diamonds. However, many diamonds today are sourced responsibly through initiatives like the Kimberley Process, which aims to prevent the sale of conflict diamonds. Additionally, lab-grown diamonds offer an ethical alternative with the same physical and chemical properties as natural diamonds. If ethical sourcing is important to you, don’t miss our selection of lab-grown diamonds.

Moissanite is typically lab-created, which means it’s an ethical and sustainable choice. Since it’s not mined, moissanite has a smaller environmental footprint, making it an attractive option for eco-conscious couples.

Resale Value: Which Holds Its Value Better?

Resale value might not be the first thing on your mind when purchasing an engagement ring, but it’s worth considering.

Diamonds generally hold their value better over time, particularly high-quality stones. While you may not get back the full amount you paid, diamonds can be resold at a reasonable price, especially if they’re accompanied by a certificate from a reputable gemological lab. To maximize the value of your investment, consider pairing your diamond ring with a timeless tennis bracelet.

Moissanite, on the other hand, does not retain its value as well. While it’s a beautiful and durable stone, its resale market is limited, and you’re unlikely to recoup much of your initial investment.

Personal Preference: Which One Is Right for You?

Ultimately, the choice between a diamond and moissanite comes down to personal preference. If you value tradition, timeless elegance, and the potential for resale value, a diamond may be the better choice. On the other hand, if you’re looking for a more affordable, ethically sourced stone with stunning brilliance, moissanite could be the perfect fit.

Many couples are now considering moissanite as a viable alternative to diamonds, especially given the rising costs of weddings and the growing importance of ethical consumerism. Whichever you choose, both gemstones offer unique beauty and lasting durability that will make your engagement ring a cherished symbol of your love.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Can you tell the difference between a diamond and moissanite?
Yes, although it can be challenging without a trained eye. Moissanite often has more colorful flashes of light, known as the "rainbow effect," while diamonds have a more subtle, icy brilliance.

Is moissanite as durable as a diamond?
Moissanite is very durable, scoring 9.25 on the Mohs scale, while diamonds score a perfect 10. Both are suitable for daily wear, though diamonds are slightly harder.

Why is moissanite cheaper than diamonds?
Moissanite is more affordable because it is lab-created and less rare than diamonds. The cost difference also reflects the traditional prestige and demand for diamonds.

Does moissanite get cloudy over time?
No, moissanite does not get cloudy. It remains clear and brilliant with proper care, similar to a diamond.

Which has better resale value, diamond or moissanite?
Diamonds generally have better resale value than moissanite, especially if they are high quality and accompanied by a certification. Moissanite’s resale market is more limited.

Is moissanite a good alternative to diamonds?
Yes, moissanite is an excellent alternative for those seeking a beautiful, durable, and ethical gemstone at a lower cost than diamonds. It offers great brilliance and a unique look that many couples find appealing.

Can I get a lab-grown diamond instead of a natural diamond or moissanite?
Absolutely. Lab-grown diamonds offer the same physical and chemical properties as natural diamonds and are often more affordable. They also provide an ethical choice with a smaller environmental footprint.

Reve Diamonds